đ Tesla's "Cheap" Model Y Controversy
đ° $5K cheaper but $8K features removed? Bait product scandal
On October 7, 2025, Tesla finally launched the "cheap" Standard Model Y in the US! đ It's $5,000 cheaper than the Premium Long Range... but something's fishy, right? đ¤ Electrek's Fred Lambert exposed this as a "reluctant bait product." They gave you a $5,000 discount but removed $6,000-$8,000 worth of features! đą Autopilot gone, cheap seats installed, APR increased 30% - the monthly payment difference is only $72! Experts call this not a good deal, but a "trick to make you buy Premium." Is this Tesla's clever strategy or a missed opportunity? We'll break it down perfectly in 3 minutes! đ
đŻ Standard Model Y Key Issues:
đ° Price difference - $5,000 cheaper than Premium
⚠️ Removed features - Worth $6,000~$8,000
đ APR trick - 30% higher than Premium
đ¸ Monthly payment - Only $72 difference
đŤ Cybertruck precedent - RWD discontinued after 6 months
đ° Price difference - $5,000 cheaper than Premium
⚠️ Removed features - Worth $6,000~$8,000
đ APR trick - 30% higher than Premium
đ¸ Monthly payment - Only $72 difference
đŤ Cybertruck precedent - RWD discontinued after 6 months
đ° Standard vs Premium Comparison
đ Complete Price & Specs Breakdown
đ Premium Long Range RWD (Existing Model)
• Price: $50,000
• Included: Autopilot (standard)
• Seats: Premium synthetic leather
• Roof: Panoramic glass roof
• Interior: Premium materials
• Battery: Full-size
• APR: ~5.74%
• Monthly payment (72 months): ~$800
đ¸ Standard Model Y (New Launch)
• Price: $45,000
• Removed: Autopilot (worth thousands)
• Seats: Cheap cloth material
• Roof: Regular headliner (no panoramic)
• Interior: Basic materials
• Battery: 125 lbs lighter reduced version
• APR: ~7.49% (30% higher!)
• Monthly payment (72 months): ~$728
đĽ Shocking Reality:
• Price difference: $5,000
• Removed features value: $6,000~$8,000
• Monthly payment difference: Only $72!
• This $72 equals the cost to upgrade Premium RWD → AWD (add motor)!
đĄ Conclusion: The illusion of "cheap"! Actually, you lose much more!
đ Premium Long Range RWD (Existing Model)
• Price: $50,000
• Included: Autopilot (standard)
• Seats: Premium synthetic leather
• Roof: Panoramic glass roof
• Interior: Premium materials
• Battery: Full-size
• APR: ~5.74%
• Monthly payment (72 months): ~$800
đ¸ Standard Model Y (New Launch)
• Price: $45,000
• Removed: Autopilot (worth thousands)
• Seats: Cheap cloth material
• Roof: Regular headliner (no panoramic)
• Interior: Basic materials
• Battery: 125 lbs lighter reduced version
• APR: ~7.49% (30% higher!)
• Monthly payment (72 months): ~$728
đĽ Shocking Reality:
• Price difference: $5,000
• Removed features value: $6,000~$8,000
• Monthly payment difference: Only $72!
• This $72 equals the cost to upgrade Premium RWD → AWD (add motor)!
đĄ Conclusion: The illusion of "cheap"! Actually, you lose much more!
⚠️ Truth Behind Removed Features
đ§ Criticized as "Reverse Value Engineering"
Fred Lambert criticized Tesla for not innovating cost reduction, but intentionally making it "shabby."
❌ 1. Autopilot Removed (Value: thousands)
• Previously standard on all Teslas
• Lane keeping, auto steering assist, etc.
• Removes Tesla's identity
• Add later: $8,000!
❌ 2. Premium Seats → Cheap Cloth
• Premium synthetic leather → Basic cloth
• Comfort & durability significantly reduced
• Lower resale value
• Savings: ~$1,000
❌ 3. Panoramic Glass Roof Removed
• Tesla's signature design
• Regular headliner instead
• Lost openness feeling
• Savings: ~$1,500
❌ 4. Premium Interior → Basic Materials
• Dashboard & door panels downgraded
• Lost luxury feel
• Savings: ~$500
⚖️ 5. Battery Pack Reduced (Only "innovation"?)
• Same cells, just fewer
• 125 lbs lighter
• But Lambert calls it "lazy approach"
• True innovation would design new lightweight battery
• Savings: ~$2,000
đĽ Total removed value: $6,000~$8,000
đ° Actual discount: $5,000
đ Net loss: $1,000~$3,000!
Fred Lambert criticized Tesla for not innovating cost reduction, but intentionally making it "shabby."
❌ 1. Autopilot Removed (Value: thousands)
• Previously standard on all Teslas
• Lane keeping, auto steering assist, etc.
• Removes Tesla's identity
• Add later: $8,000!
❌ 2. Premium Seats → Cheap Cloth
• Premium synthetic leather → Basic cloth
• Comfort & durability significantly reduced
• Lower resale value
• Savings: ~$1,000
❌ 3. Panoramic Glass Roof Removed
• Tesla's signature design
• Regular headliner instead
• Lost openness feeling
• Savings: ~$1,500
❌ 4. Premium Interior → Basic Materials
• Dashboard & door panels downgraded
• Lost luxury feel
• Savings: ~$500
⚖️ 5. Battery Pack Reduced (Only "innovation"?)
• Same cells, just fewer
• 125 lbs lighter
• But Lambert calls it "lazy approach"
• True innovation would design new lightweight battery
• Savings: ~$2,000
đĽ Total removed value: $6,000~$8,000
đ° Actual discount: $5,000
đ Net loss: $1,000~$3,000!
đł Hidden Financing Trap
𪤠APR Trick Neutralizes Price Difference
Tesla didn't just lower the price - they used financing terms to nearly eliminate the real cost difference!
đ APR Comparison:
• Standard Model: ~7.49%
• Premium Model: ~5.74%
• Difference: ~30% higher!
đ° 72-Month Financing Calculation:
• Standard: $45,000 @ 7.49% → $728/month
• Premium: $50,000 @ 5.74% → $800/month
• Difference: Only $72/month!
𤯠Shocking Comparison:
This $72 difference equals the cost to upgrade Premium RWD to AWD (dual motor)!
Same money gets you:
① Standard + no features
② Premium + dual motor added
Which would you choose? đ¤
đŤ No Lease Option:
• Common for new launches, but still disappointing
• Excludes buyers who prefer leasing
• Another mechanism pushing Premium
đĄ Conclusion: Price tag looks cheap, but APR trap makes real cost nearly identical!
Tesla didn't just lower the price - they used financing terms to nearly eliminate the real cost difference!
đ APR Comparison:
• Standard Model: ~7.49%
• Premium Model: ~5.74%
• Difference: ~30% higher!
đ° 72-Month Financing Calculation:
• Standard: $45,000 @ 7.49% → $728/month
• Premium: $50,000 @ 5.74% → $800/month
• Difference: Only $72/month!
𤯠Shocking Comparison:
This $72 difference equals the cost to upgrade Premium RWD to AWD (dual motor)!
Same money gets you:
① Standard + no features
② Premium + dual motor added
Which would you choose? đ¤
đŤ No Lease Option:
• Common for new launches, but still disappointing
• Excludes buyers who prefer leasing
• Another mechanism pushing Premium
đĄ Conclusion: Price tag looks cheap, but APR trap makes real cost nearly identical!
đ Cybertruck RWD Lesson
⚠️ History Repeats - Discontinued After 6 Months
Tesla already ran this exact experiment and failed!
đ Cybertruck RWD Timeline:
• April 2025: Launched
• $10,000 cheaper than AWD
• But removed $20,000 worth of features
• Sales flopped
• September 2025: Discontinued (only 6 months!)
đ Will Model Y Standard Follow?
• Same pattern: Lower price, remove more features
• Makes Premium look attractive
• "Bait" role rather than real sales
• Expected quiet discontinuation in 6 months~1 year
đ Tesla's Intent:
"Look, we have a cheap car! But will you actually buy it? Premium is way better, right?"
đ Expected Scenario:
① Standard sales flop
② End-of-quarter emergency discount or 0% APR
③ Temporary sales bump (10~15%)
④ Eventually quietly discontinued
⑤ Announce "there was no demand"
đĄ Truth: Never intended to sell many from the start!
Tesla already ran this exact experiment and failed!
đ Cybertruck RWD Timeline:
• April 2025: Launched
• $10,000 cheaper than AWD
• But removed $20,000 worth of features
• Sales flopped
• September 2025: Discontinued (only 6 months!)
đ Will Model Y Standard Follow?
• Same pattern: Lower price, remove more features
• Makes Premium look attractive
• "Bait" role rather than real sales
• Expected quiet discontinuation in 6 months~1 year
đ Tesla's Intent:
"Look, we have a cheap car! But will you actually buy it? Premium is way better, right?"
đ Expected Scenario:
① Standard sales flop
② End-of-quarter emergency discount or 0% APR
③ Temporary sales bump (10~15%)
④ Eventually quietly discontinued
⑤ Announce "there was no demand"
đĄ Truth: Never intended to sell many from the start!
đ Tesla's Crisis & Strategy Misjudgment
đ US Demand Slump & Factory Utilization
Behind the Standard Model Y launch is Tesla's serious crisis.
đ Current Situation:
• US factory utilization: ~60%
• 1.5 years building expectations for "cheap new car"
• But delivered this half-baked Standard model
• Competitors flooding market with better value EVs
đ Competition Status:
• Hyundai Ioniq 5: Excellent value
• Kia EV6: Great design & performance
• Ford Mustang Mach-E: Popular in US
• VW ID.4: Outstanding practicality
• Tesla leads in efficiency but criticized for "complacency"
đĄ Model 3 Standard is Different:
Recently launched new Standard Model 3 has much better value!
• Fewer features removed
• Reasonable financing terms
• Actually affordable entry model
→ Budget buyers should get Model 3 instead of Model Y!
đ¨ Risk Factors:
• Short-term margins vs long-term market share
• Risk of losing mass market while clinging to premium
• Competitors rapidly closing gap
• Potential brand image damage
Behind the Standard Model Y launch is Tesla's serious crisis.
đ Current Situation:
• US factory utilization: ~60%
• 1.5 years building expectations for "cheap new car"
• But delivered this half-baked Standard model
• Competitors flooding market with better value EVs
đ Competition Status:
• Hyundai Ioniq 5: Excellent value
• Kia EV6: Great design & performance
• Ford Mustang Mach-E: Popular in US
• VW ID.4: Outstanding practicality
• Tesla leads in efficiency but criticized for "complacency"
đĄ Model 3 Standard is Different:
Recently launched new Standard Model 3 has much better value!
• Fewer features removed
• Reasonable financing terms
• Actually affordable entry model
→ Budget buyers should get Model 3 instead of Model Y!
đ¨ Risk Factors:
• Short-term margins vs long-term market share
• Risk of losing mass market while clinging to premium
• Competitors rapidly closing gap
• Potential brand image damage
đ¤ Expert & Consumer Reactions
đŹ Electrek Fred Lambert's Harsh Criticism
"Reluctantly launched bait product"
Lambert is a famous Tesla fan and EV expert. Even he strongly criticized this Standard Model Y.
Key Criticism Points:
① "Reverse value engineering" - No real innovation
② "Lazy approach" - Just removed features
③ "Upselling trick" - Bait to sell Premium
④ "Complacent attitude" - Tesla's innovation spirit gone
đŁ️ Consumer Reactions (US Forums):
Negative (Majority):
"What's the point of $5K discount when you remove $8K features?"
"APR makes total cost same. Feel scammed"
"They're just telling us to buy Premium"
"I'm a Tesla fan but disappointed"
Positive (Minority):
"At least entry barrier is lower"
"I like that unnecessary features are removed"
"Smaller battery charges faster, right?"
đ Opinion Summary:
70% negative vs 30% positive - overwhelming disappointment!
"Reluctantly launched bait product"
Lambert is a famous Tesla fan and EV expert. Even he strongly criticized this Standard Model Y.
Key Criticism Points:
① "Reverse value engineering" - No real innovation
② "Lazy approach" - Just removed features
③ "Upselling trick" - Bait to sell Premium
④ "Complacent attitude" - Tesla's innovation spirit gone
đŁ️ Consumer Reactions (US Forums):
Negative (Majority):
"What's the point of $5K discount when you remove $8K features?"
"APR makes total cost same. Feel scammed"
"They're just telling us to buy Premium"
"I'm a Tesla fan but disappointed"
Positive (Minority):
"At least entry barrier is lower"
"I like that unnecessary features are removed"
"Smaller battery charges faster, right?"
đ Opinion Summary:
70% negative vs 30% positive - overwhelming disappointment!
Q. Is Standard Model Y worth buying?
Honestly, not recommended. đ
Paying $72 more per month for Premium RWD is much better, and for the same money, AWD upgrade has more value. If budget is really tight, get the new Standard Model 3 instead! Much better value. Standard Model Y is likely a "bait product" and may be discontinued in 6 months~1 year. Resale value will be low too. đ¸
Q. Should I wait for end-of-quarter discount?
Good strategy! đŻ Tesla frequently offers aggressive discounts at quarter-end (March, June, September, December) to hit sales targets. With expected Standard sales flop, 0% APR or additional discount likely. Wait 2~3 months and you might get $2,000~$5,000 extra off! But inventory may be limited, so timing matters. ⏰
Q. Why did Tesla choose this strategy?
Appears to be a strategy to protect short-term margins. đ° Tesla has the highest margin rate among EVs (~25~30%). A truly cheap car would lower margins. So they throw "cheap bait" while actually trying to sell Premium. The problem is this short-term strategy risks losing long-term brand trust and market share. đ¨
đŹ What's Your Take?
Tesla's clever upselling strategy? Or missed opportunity?
Share your thoughts in comments! đŹ
Tesla's clever upselling strategy? Or missed opportunity?
Share your thoughts in comments! đŹ
đŻ Conclusion: Standard Model Y Truth
đ° Price: $5,000 cheaper (surface level)
⚠️ Reality: $6,000~$8,000 features removed
đł APR: 30% higher makes monthly payment nearly same
đŤ Precedent: Cybertruck RWD discontinued after 6 months
đ Recommendation: Premium RWD or Model 3 Standard
đĄ Tesla's "cheap" is an illusion! Calculate carefully and make smart choice!
đ° Price: $5,000 cheaper (surface level)
⚠️ Reality: $6,000~$8,000 features removed
đł APR: 30% higher makes monthly payment nearly same
đŤ Precedent: Cybertruck RWD discontinued after 6 months
đ Recommendation: Premium RWD or Model 3 Standard
đĄ Tesla's "cheap" is an illusion! Calculate carefully and make smart choice!
#Tesla #ModelY #StandardModelY #ElectricVehicle #TeslaPrice #EV #ElonMusk #Car #ValueForMoney #BaitProduct
![ë°íë¤ě [ĺĺ¸ĺ¤č] íęł í..](http://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgNSzSmBhvul6Pch05-iZA4pjYVc3mXTbvKSykJn5SW5AilzvB3XU96hJaCvqm4OpA42i7BXx8Jt2sd80DsjEZjNO1SqiY5jnYqTUcooKihq_z14qdLzr_M-VZxNJ8zAU795pUk8KRH_yyOVVypCN7GnrZocZvtDYWAgLCIMIJPBTF8C14/w100/%EB%B0%95%ED%95%99%EB%8B%A4%EC%8B%9D.png)
